Welcome to the Progressively Incorrect podcast. I’m Dr. Zach Groshell, and in this episode, I welcome my friend Beth Hawks to talk about her new book, Show Your Work: Teaching Smarter with the Science of Learning. Beth taught middle and high school science for 25 years, and she wrote the book because most of what she had read about the science of learning felt a little too tidy next to what actually happens in a classroom.
We talk about the 10 ideas she chose to include, starting with working memory and clarity and ending with formative assessment, and why each chapter closes with stories from real teachers whose classrooms she knew well. Beth explains why trial and error isn’t good enough when the research already exists, why these principles carry over from science to English, history and the arts, why shared approaches across a school still need room for professional judgment, and where a teacher who is new to the science of learning should start.
In this episode
- Why write another science of learning book? [0:01:39]
- Which 10 ideas made the cut, and why start with working memory and clarity? [0:04:23]
- What do interviews with real teachers add? [0:06:39]
- From two decades of trial and error to the Learning and the Brain conference [0:08:23]
- Is the science of learning only for science teachers? [0:11:33]
- Why should kids have to wait for teachers to figure it out on their own? [0:13:45]
- Should a school standardize its approaches? [0:15:16]
- Where should a teacher new to the science of learning start? [0:17:10]
- What’s inside the book, and Beth’s advice for getting started [0:18:23]
Show full transcript
Progressively Incorrect. Speakers: Zach Groshell (host), Beth Hawks (author of Show Your Work) – Auto-transcribed.
Zach: Hello everyone, welcome back to Progressively Incorrect. My name is Zach Groshell and I’m so excited today to be talking to my friend Beth Hawks about her new book and just updating us on the science of learning and the movement surrounding it. I’m just extremely tickled to have Beth on here. She’s a super, super smart educator who we’ve been in cahoots and talking for some time, so it’s great to hear her. But before I turn over to Beth, I just wanted to plug the Explicit Teaching Institute, which I’m going to put a lot of focus into that one because the first annual Explicit Teaching Institute took place in the summer of 2026 and it was so successful and so well attended that I’m doing it again.
So look out for any updates. I haven’t quite put it out there for you to purchase just yet, but look out for any updates and this podcast will keep on talking about it. I’d love to see you in New York City for that event. One week of excellent training and spectacular food in New York City all about the science of learning and explicit instruction. Beth, how are you doing? Welcome finally to the podcast.
Beth: Hey Zach, I’m doing well and can I just say I’m happy to know there is an Explicit Teaching Institute. Like that’s an awesome thing that is very much needed.
Zach: Oh it was so fun. Of course you’re invited. I’ll give you a free ticket. Beth, I’m so happy to hear that you are now an author and a new book coming out and I just want to hear a little bit about it. Tell us about this book you’ve been working on.
Beth: So thank you. When I stepped out of the classroom I had learned so much about the science of learning and I had been presenting to my colleagues in my school and I was like I really want to spread this farther and wider, speak at conferences, go to other schools and part of that was to talk about what I had learned and how it impacted my classroom. In the writing of this book what I did was I wanted to address the messiness because most of the books I had read, which I love, I absolutely love them, they were either written by researchers in science lingo which can be hard to parse, but that’s great because you’re hearing directly from the researchers, or they had been written by translators which is a good thing, but they all just seemed a little neat, like a little tidy and I’d be like hmm my classroom is a lot messier than that.
And also it looks different in 7th grade or science than it does in AP bio. So I kind of wanted to gather stories from real teachers, make it really practical. What does this look like with different age kids, with different topics, with different subject matter? While the principles are all still the same, it’s going to be adapted differently in different classrooms. So that’s what I kind of wanted to reflect in the writing of it.
Zach: It’s funny when you start to write stuff, how it really does force you to kind of think through and it can analyze your priors I guess, as some people call it. But with this particular topic there are a lot of books that had been written. I often recommend for example, Why Don’t Students Like School? by Dan Willingham. There’s been a lot of saturation in the science of learning book market. I would say, what does this book bring? Why did you think this was so needed?
Beth: Okay, first of all that book is a gem and I wish I had read it earlier in my life. But I think I needed something that was like, I’m doing this in the classroom, so are the other people whose voices you’re going to hear. It might look different in 3rd period than it does in 5th. And that’s what I wasn’t finding in the other books, was something that kind of acknowledged the messiness or the reality of classrooms. And so not everything is going to work instantly, like what challenges did you encounter? And that kind of thing were the questions that I wanted to have addressed in a book. And so since I wasn’t seeing that in other books, I figured I needed to write about it.
Zach: Awesome. And I’d like to dig in a little bit now about like which elements of the science of learning you chose to include, right? Sometimes, right, when you’re talking about a whole body of knowledge, right? You have to make choices on what to emphasize, what would be like great for a first year teacher or what would be great for a more as a more of an advanced tactic, I suppose. So tell me, what did you choose to include in this book that you think everybody should know about?
Beth: So, yeah, that was the hard part because I had gotten so into this world that I could have easily written about like 87 things and made a book nobody wanted to read because it was too long. So I kind of limited myself to 10. I was like a top 10 is kind of something most people would find approachable. And then I thought about what had made the biggest impact in my classroom. So like planning with working memory and clarity in mind, that was big for me, because we try to cram so much in that sometimes it’s like we end up teaching nothing because we’re trying to teach too much and understanding working memory was helpful with that. So that’s what I started the book with.
And then chapter two is clarity, because I feel like if you kind of get those two things down, it affects everything that comes after. And then retrieval was, I mean, I think all teachers have done retrieval for a long time, but doing it like intentionally, kind of what I learned from some of the conferences we’ve attended, I would, I started putting a whiteboard on every desk, I started doing stuff where I knew I was getting an answer from every kid every time. So I was doing it with a lot more purpose. And I wanted to kind of explain that as well. And then I also talked to I ended the book with formative assessment, because I felt like you can implement all this other stuff.
If you don’t know that the kids are actually learning it, you’re not really helping. Right? Like you got to know if they’re picking up what you’re putting down in the process. And so that’s sort of how I spanned that book was from, okay, I’m lesson planning with working memory in mind. So in class, I’ve got to think about what they’re learning, how this is working out, how can I adapt to it. So yeah, I chose kind of the top 10 of what had made an impact in my room. And then I thought I could reasonably ask other teachers about.
Zach: Yeah, and about asking other teachers, like a lot of the book includes interviews of middle school teachers, high school science teachers, tell me about your choice to involve teachers in this book. What do they bring to the conversation around the science of learning?
Beth: Even though they’re all science teachers, they brought a breadth of perspective. I could only speak to what I had done with my eighth graders and with my physics students. Whereas I talked to the sixth grade science teacher who her schedule is different. She only has them three times a week and you know, for shorter periods of time. And I talked to the AP teachers, which I never was one because I didn’t want to teach college. And so it gave like a wide variety. And the only reason I chose all science teachers was that those were the ones I had the easiest access to and who I had observed multiple times. Because I was their department chair, I had seen them teach over and over and over again.
I shared walls with three of them. You know, they were right around my classroom, so I could literally hear how they were implementing things. And so that made it something that I knew that I’d be able to know that what they were telling me was true and that I kind of had an idea of what answers they were going to give me because I just knew them so well. But it’s not just for science teachers, for sure. That’s where a lot of the examples are. But I think this is good for K through 12 college group fitness instructors, Sunday school teachers. If you’re if you’re teaching anybody anything, they have the science of learning should be involved because you want your people to learn.
So I feel like anybody reading this should be able to adapt it to whatever area they’re in.
Zach: There’s obviously a gap between like these conferences that we visit that are filled with folks who sort of self selected in to visit the conference. And they’ve they’ve all read some of the same things and they share the same link. And then just like your everyday classroom, which is facing the messiness of teaching real children. And so like maybe tell me a little bit more about your own experience. Like what was it that you found initially to be hard to troubleshoot or difficult to translate from perhaps the more abstract recommendations that you would find on social media or in education conferences?
Beth: Yeah, so I I didn’t find this world until about 2018. That’s not 100% true, because I have read a couple of books. I’ve been teaching 17 years before I found this. And I feel like so much with teachers like even if you have an education degree, you go out and finding out what works is a lot of trial and error if you don’t have something like this. And so I think I had become a very good teacher, but it was through making tons and tons and tons of mistakes to figure out what works and I should hang on to and what I should dump. And and it’s a little scary to think you’re experimenting on kids, right? Like finding out what doesn’t work came from somebody not getting what they should have.
And so when I the first conference I attended was a Learning and the Brain conference in 2018. I had gotten just one of those brochures in my mailbox at school and I was on my way to the trash can with it like you do. And and just somebody caught my attention and I was like, oh, let me let me look at this. And I was like, there, this is this looks great. This looks important. This looks like something I want to go to. So I begged my school to send me and they basically said, yeah, if you’ll present what you learned about when you get back, you know, then we’ll send you. And I was overwhelmed when I got there at like the idea that we had done enough research on the brain that it could be translated into advice and why had no one given me this advice before.
And so, yeah, it was it was eye opening. At the same time, I don’t know that it radically changed my practice because the trial and error had gotten me to a good place. It just took two decades to get there. But knowing how it worked and understanding it, being able to have the conversation with kids. The reason I titled the book Show Your Work is I think we should explain all this to students too. So that we’re showing our thinking on why we’re doing those things and helping them to understand how they learn is motivating and helpful for them. So I came back just ready to go. And and I did a presentation that year and then the next year I went back to the conference and I said, I think I could do six presentations.
Can we do like a class where people sign up and get CEU credit for it? And so I was wanting to get it to the people who weren’t going to the conference weren’t self selecting for the conference, but would listen to me. And and so it had a big impact, I think, on on the school I was in.
Zach: It seems like there’s this belief that like instruction and best practices are kind of, I don’t know, locked into certain subjects and that they can’t apply more broadly. What was your thinking when talking to all these science teachers? Did you feel that there was a great deal of it that would apply to all aspects of human learning or was it was it really really super subject specific?
Beth: No, I don’t think it is. And I’ll tell you a story about why. So I did a presentation in a faculty meeting one day. I was pushing the mini whiteboards pretty hard because I know my school well enough. I knew like there’s going to be certain people who will latch on to this. And a couple of weeks later, the seventh grade English teacher came to me who, by the way, was also my student. And and she said, oh, my gosh, this is a game changer. And so we spent 20 minutes nerding out about and she was telling me how she used it in English, which was a little bit different than how I was using it in science and some of it for retrieval, some of it for formative assessment and prediction.
And she said, and I’m hearing from my introverts, which is the best part. So like we had we had this great conversation coming from two very like opposite ends of the spectrum, but both had found it really useful. And the history teacher that I worked with, too, she started like adding certain aspects of things. And so no, I don’t I don’t think it is. Our our theater and dance teacher came to me one day and said she she was speaking at a conference because she said, I want to talk about how this applies in an arts classroom. So yeah, I don’t think it’s locked in at all. I think it’s easier to think that because science teachers know how to look at a research paper and pull things out from it.
Whereas somebody who hasn’t been trained in that might need somebody to translate things, right. Like Andrew Watson or Barbara Oakley or Zach Groshell to tell them not just what the research says, but actually turn that into practical advice, because, yeah, science language is awful or it’s hard to it’s hard to parse.
Zach: You mentioned the trial and error piece, and that’s what a lot of us have had to do is is figure out with students how to based on their own performance, on their own reactions, looking at their assessments, figuring out that over time, certain tactics seem to rise to the top. But it seems like this divides education and educators a little bit in that like I personally just don’t think that that’s good enough. Like the idea that children should wait for five years for a teacher to be able to figure out all these things, essentially discover the science of learning through trial and error just to do such a big disservice to all five years of those children who had to go through that.
I don’t know if you’re thinking along the same thing as I am.
Beth: I am and you know, be one thing if we didn’t know if the research didn’t exist, but it does. Right. So yeah, 56 years ago, you could make a case for the fact that people had to use trial and error. They don’t have to anymore. And so yeah, that was the big eye opener for me when I got there. I was like, oh, we know what works and why it works. Like really, this is not something I had any idea about before. But yeah, I do. I totally agree with you. Like the only way to do it by trial and error is to experiment on kids. And that’s that’s a little scary to think that, you know, there’s a failure rate involved that has to then be made up for by somebody down the road.
Zach: And on that note, you worked with a lot of different teachers and different departments. Would there be any benefit in sort of standardizing a set of common approaches that could allow teachers to talk with each other in more efficient ways to share certain techniques, how they’re working out for them, like if they’re shared, and then also like creates a bit of predictability for students when they go across different different grade levels and, you know, and change teachers so much?
Beth: Yes, and a little bit no. So yes, the principles of the science of learning are definitely applicable across the board. And so having kind of a shared understanding of that, I think is useful. The application of it is going to look different. So I don’t think it has to be look exactly the same in every classroom. I think predictability is good, but also you want the kids to understand they’re being taught by a human being and not like a teaching robot. Right. So that there is professional judgment involved in the choices we make. And I definitely had times where like I did something second period, it was working great. And third period, I’d be like, well, what is happening?
And you know, like, this is not working out the same way in here. So there needs to be some flexibility within it. Yes, I think that that is a good idea as long as there is some. I don’t want people to think like that the science of learning places you in a tiny box and like this is what a good teacher looks like. And this is only what a good teacher looks like. I think I think there’s just there’s room for art in the science of learning as well.
Zach: Great. Sort of like science informed, but then the application of that science often takes on its own forms. Doesn’t it? I’m curious if you had to draw from, you know, your investigation, your research for this book, what concept would you advise our listeners to learn about first, you know, especially if they were brand new to the science of learning?
Beth: Yeah. So if you want to start with a topic, I would say start with working memory. And you and I have a shared friend in Andrew Watson. This book, Learning Begins, is a great place to start for a number of reasons. One, it’s an easy read. It’s not technical. Andrew is a great, great communicator. But also because if you get the idea of working memory down first, it kind of makes everything else work better. Because if you’re saying, okay, I need to chunk things and sequence them in a way that’s not going to overwhelm the working memory and you know when you need to pause, that might also be a good time to engage in a little retrieval or do some formative assessment or get them into diffuse mode for a minute where like everything else kind of fits under that umbrella.
If you want to start with a broad overview, then I would say start with Why Don’t Students Like School. But if you want to start with one topic, then I would recommend Andrew’s Learning Begins.
Zach: For you know, for listeners who are like, oh, I can’t wait to see, you know, your book come out, tell me about it, the timeline and the and what you can expect when you crack open these pages.
Beth: Okay, so it is out. It came out on the sixth. And I don’t know how many I sold at this point. I’m trying to communicate with the publishers. But yeah, as far as what you can expect, every chapter starts with a story because I just found that a good way to enter. I kind of wanted to set the tone for each chapter. Some of them are from my classroom. Some of them are from my childhood, my own learning experiences. A couple of them have to do with group fitness at the Y because when I started going there, I was seeing the implementation of this in a very different context and going, oh, wait, that’s retrieval practice. That’s modeling and scaffolding, right?
Like it was actually really super interesting to see it outside the academic world. So I start every chapter with a story to kind of say like, this is this is a kind of guide you into this. And then I the middle of the chapter is is the research. So I quote a lot of the books I’ve read, I kind of wanted to put everybody in one place and then have teachers say, oh, I really like what that person had to say about that. Let me go read their book. Right. So there’s a ton of other people referenced. And then the end of the chapter has the stories from the people I interviewed to say like, now this is what this looks like if you’re implementing it in different classes.
Zach: Excellent, excellent. Super, super excited for you. I just I love this opportunity to highlight this book that you put so much energy into and listeners, I will be sure to provide the links to Beth’s stuff in the show notes. So go ahead and check out the show notes and you know, and click on the links and check out the Explicit Teaching Institute among other things that were mentioned on this podcast. And listeners, thank you so much for tuning in to Progressively Incorrect. Beth, I suppose the floor is yours. Like do you have, you know, a call to action? Not to put you on the spot, but just a bit of a bit of some final final words as we close out this episode.
Beth: Yeah, I would say don’t be intimidated by the science of learning. It can be intimidating to look at what is out there. There’s a wealth of knowledge. Pick something and start there and do the best you can with it. And then when you feel like you got that down, pick something else, right? You’re not going to do it all at once and it wouldn’t be healthy for your brain or the kids brains if you tried because it would just be overwhelming and also recognizing that it looks different. Can I let me shout out one of the teachers that I interviewed in particular. Her name is Hannah and she was my student. She was also in my department for a long time.
By the time I interviewed her, she was at another school. So she had a good amount of experience. I knew her answers were going to be very different than everybody else’s. And I was excited for that because I felt like it really showcased that this doesn’t have to look one way. I asked her how much she has students memorize and everybody else had said oh, it’s on and she said, oh, as little as possible. But I had observed her enough times that I had seen her doing retrieval practice with her kids a lot. When she said as little as possible, what she meant was I don’t give them a list of things to memorize and say there’s going to be a quiz on Friday.
But they were doing so much retrieval. They were definitely memorizing things. I loved that I got to include that because I feel like we do get locked into that. Don’t think it has to look one way would be my advice to anybody because that you’re going to find intimidating. You’re going to be like, I can’t reach this perfect model. Whereas if you look at the principles and say, how can I adapt this to my kids and my classroom and my content? It’s actually really fun and it’s really interesting. And once the kids start getting success out of it, they find it really motivating, which actually makes your classroom experience also a lot better. So I think just start somewhere would be my advice.
If you look at a list of topics, and one of them appeals to you more. I still would advise starting with working in memory. But if you look at something going, no, I’d rather start with this. I don’t think you can do that wrong. I think just starting from somewhere and getting better at it each day would be my advice.
Zach: And for us over here in North America, this is the beginning of the school year when this was recorded. So what better advice than to pick something and don’t feel like you have to be stuck in a holding pattern when it comes to instruction. You’re often given enough degrees of freedom to just attempt something within the constraints that you have within the curriculum and the structures you have. So I also, I will echo what you said, Beth. I think it’s great to choose something manageable, pursue it, and then get on social media and contact me and Beth about how it’s going. Listeners, thank you so much for tuning in, as usual, to Progressively Incorrect.
Take care.
Links to resources
When we mention helpful resources in the podcast, we want you to be able to find them!
- Show Your Work: Teaching Smarter with the Science of Learning – Beth Hawks (Bloomsbury)
- Show Your Work on Amazon
- The Learning Hawk – Beth’s website
- Beth Hawks on X (@PhysicsHawk)
- My Learning and the Brain Story – Beth Hawks
- Learning Begins: The Science of Working Memory and Attention for the Classroom Teacher – Andrew Watson
- Why Don’t Students Like School? – Daniel Willingham
- Learning and the Brain conferences
The Explicit Teaching Institute is coming back
The first Explicit Teaching Institute in New York City last summer went so well that I’m running it again. Registration just opened, and you can find it here.
Check out my latest book, Just Tell Them: The Power of Explanations and Explicit Teaching.
More about our guest
Beth Hawks taught middle and high school science for 25 years, including 17 years as science department chair at GRACE Christian School in Raleigh, North Carolina. A graduate of Oral Roberts University, she has taught physical science, physics, chemistry, algebra, health and photography, and wrote her own in-house textbooks for physical science and physics. After attending the Learning and the Brain conference in 2018, she began teaching her colleagues about the science of learning, and she now consults full time as The Learning Hawk, presenting at conferences and providing professional development. Her book, Show Your Work, was published by Bloomsbury Academic in 2026.



